Alright, now see... the first one was perfect.
Then ya had to do... whatever the second and third ones were.

Base +7, Majin420 +7, George642 +9, Tomzai +6, repeatedmeme +9, Yamioni +9, dsgturuhgjhgk +6, blarghin123 +6, lishde1 +10, noahb3 +7, Bravely +6, eaee +5, HouraiHime +6, and 10 more...

Pink, just chose the pink

Base +6, George642 +9, repeatedmeme +9, Yamioni +9, blarghin123 +6, noahb3 +7, borkenbea +11, Kues +6, Invisibleguest +6, yichuan321 +3, mayasama +6, neoshingundam +1, Sheras +7, and 4 more...

Agreed. Stay with pink. Make the other potions variants of the first. Maybe make purple a troll female or something. Everybody would be happy.

Base +6, GibLkt -4

This is pretty much every D&D campaign at 1st level when there isn't a spellcaster in the party to identify potions.

I suspect that the artist was channelling their inner rage at their character having drunk a baleful polymorph potion whilst desperately searching for a potion of cure serious wounds.

Base +2, D u b b y +9, weidenritter +12, banjomarx +8, SxSov +5, Poe mk.II +6, Kues +6, Dothion +5, Turbotowns +6

This! I like this!

Base +14

@Sylvrwolfol

Yeah, that's probably around 2/3 of Western Gender bender art for me.
I really like the first part of several artists' stories, then suddenly there's something that is just silly for me.

Base +6, Myzer +10