I’m voting a 3 out of 5. It’s a cute concept and I applaud the effort. The dialogue is a bit stiff and parts of it don’t really capture the kind of playfulness I associate with Sayori, like if I was just shown the dialogue with names removed and told it was a DDLC girl I would have guessed Natsuki or Monika for most of it, although the choice of naked apron is definitely a Sayori kind of thing to do.
The art isn’t great but I don’t draw, so you’re already doing better than me and most other people. Don’t get discouraged by the low score for now, the only way to get better is to draw more. Everyone has a million good drawings in them waiting to come out but before they can you have to get all the not so great ones out