Done by https://www.deviantart.com/jesscatg

According to the tag definitions, the feminization of a male into a shemale is NOT a gender change.

Base +7, timonator14 +7, tisist +7, Vonsta +6, jehaknaboom -22, ZeldaGuy21 +6, Mags_ -30, Cipher-kun -30, aoz +8, peterson123 -30, firebomber -8, Iphroget +6, bladezz +8, and 5 more...

@IngmarS Incorrect, the tag definitions do not say that. It only says a female character becoming futanari doesn't count.

For all intents and purposes, gender change is when the correct tags for a character change sexes. And since the protagonist changes from a normal guy to a shemale character (which is categorized as female) therefore they went from male to female. That is gender change, and gender morph.

Base +15, jehaknaboom +22, ZeldaGuy21 -6, Vanilla GB lover +6, Iphroget -6, bladezz -8, Jazzy81 -11, Nemesis07 -7

Once again, you only read the "gender change" tag. That is not the relevant tag…

feminization

Description: A male has his lifestyle modified into that of a crossdresser (e.g. via training or mind control) or has his body altered into that of a shemale/futanari. In either case the person must act or be treated as more feminine.

Notes: May invoke m:crossdressing; invokes m:gender change if his gender actually changes.

https://ehwiki.org/wiki/feminization

Base +7, jehaknaboom -22, ZeldaGuy21 +6, Mags_ -30, Cipher-kun -30, Iphroget +6, Jazzy81 +11, Robin_WH +6, just Zombie +7, Anonimous1234567890 +6, noitem1 -6

Again Ingy, that doesn't back up your argument. As far as feminization tag goes, the crossdressing tag is for when it doesn't result in gender change, going no further than just an outfit/lifestyle change. The Shemale tag is for when it does.

Edit: Love you too, guys. lol

Last edited on 27 August 2023, 03:20.

Base +15, ZeldaGuy21 -6, Iphroget -6, Jazzy81 -11

I love gender bender stuff, but actual surgical modification involving cutting someone open and putting them back together is a huge turn off. I'm pretty sure that's the reason most gender bender fetish porn (and also non-porn gender bender stuff even if containing nudity and fanservice like Ranma 1/2, Kämpfer, Fabiniku, and Gonna be the Twin-Tail) uses magic and scifi style transformations. When blades explicitly come out for the transformation it seems like much more visceral body horror than fetish fantasy even if the end result shown manages to be far more perfect than anything in real life. Much better when surgery is only implied like most brain swap stuff too where they usually don't actually show scalpels and surgical dotted lines.

Last edited on 26 August 2023, 01:48.

Base +6, bladezz +8, Kues +6, hellocakeguy +6, carjua +10

Hahahahaha those grammatical and orthographic errors are so dumb hahahahaha that's the real turn off not your stupid debate about if tags are wrong and if shemale are gender swap or whatever the fuck you discuss

Base +6

@junko_9

Agreed, grammar and wording is pretty bad. The text kind of sounds like whoever wrote it doesn't know English well and was writing based off bad pornos. The characters in this are laughably perverted in speech. Doesn't sound like how anyone would actually talk outside of porn. I don't get why he's so compliant after forced surgery like that either as there's no explicit mind control, mind break, or hypnosis like other gender bender porn. What surgery was he even going into this place for to start with? Was he just there to fuck the nurses? It's a crummy world of plot holes and spelling errors.

Base +6, Robin_WH +6

@junko_9 and @Grey_Ghost: I agree with both of your statements

Base +9

@Grey_Ghost that's always been a problem with Jessca, and for a while Kannel too.

But Kannel actually resorted to getting help with Grammar from folks on her Discord, while I think Jessca just doesn't care. lol

Base +15

The only two assholes who give a shit about 'proper tagging' are Ingmar and Pseudo-Nim.

For what it's worth, we went from having one tag, "Gender Bender", to something like seven, making it ridiculously difficult to search for it when one worked just perfectly fine.

Base +6, just Zombie -7

Honestly, seeing a native English speaker making the most childish grammar mistakes, especially in something he gets paid for, is embarrassing to say the least.

Base +6

"This is my life now" ending.

Art 6. Plot 4. Sexiness 5. English 4. All out of 10.

Base +10