Scans by yurihou.se

Thanks for uploading this. Really love Torinone's work. It'd be even better with a translation!

Base +5, Commander Kickasss +6, @43883 +35, Mantama +9

@jjdotam

>protesting fluffy romance stories as insulting the characters and treating them as disposable garbage
>paying no heed to the stories where Homura gets tentacle raped to death
>still keeping up the retarded crusade as if it has ever made any headway into anything

Don't you have 4chan bans to evade?

Base +6, Gattix +6, Chedring +4, Commander Kickasss +6, poldek123 +5, @43883 +35, Mantama +9

You know what? The reason people downvote you isn't because you're some sterling silver dreamer who bestows his enlightened knowledge onto us. They downvote you because you're Monty Python's Black Knight, still charging away at the same crusade even though you've lost all your arms and legs. Your arguments have been taken apart a thousand different ways on about seven different sites, and yet you still continue to post them. So all we can do is report your posts on /u/ and have the mods come along and ban you. Again.

But fine, I'll play your game. You say I'm disrespecting the character's feelings by reading this doujin. And you know what? Nobody gives a shit. They're not real. Here, watch this: Mami, you're a fat stupid whore and your boobs are implants. Do you hear that? It's the sound of crickets chirping, because Mami is not real and does not care about my insults. Mami and Sayaka are fictional characters and exist entirely to entertain. Since this doujin has a 4.15 rating, I can only assume it's doing exactly that. So yes, I am fulfilling a shallow whim by reading this doujin. I also fulfilled a shallow whim by watching the original series, and by reading other doujins where non-MamiSaya pairings end up together. And so do the people who like tentacle rape. I don't, but I don't mind them for it. They have their kinks and I have mine.

And you know what? You say it ruins the characters by not making them act like their canon selves. To which I respond, so the fuck what? There are hundreds of doujins that show Kyouko and Sayaka in an open sexual relationship, which they certainly weren't in canon. Why is it in-character for a fourteen-year-old girl to shove her fist up her similarly-aged girlfriend's vagina, but out of character to show Mami and Sayaka... talking? Because that's pretty much all they do here. And why is it some kind of horrible sin against them to show them having interest in other people? I don't know if you know this, but a person is not expected to marry their first romantic partner. Most people have many romantic interests over the course of their lives, trying to figure out if the one they meet is the one they want to be with (but I'd imagine you wouldn't know anything about romance). The fact that you consider a person not being with their canon paramour to be an equivalent "insult" to them being gangraped is naive at best and sickening at worst.

And finally, so what if it's not canon? It's a fucking fan comic. The entire purpose of a fan comic is to show things that didn't happen in canon. If all a fan comic did was blandly mimic canon, then it would be fucking boring. It would be the same shit we've seen already. Variety is the spice of life, and an active fan community willing to experiment is a sign that the fandom is thriving and strong. And why the fuck do you care? MadoHomu and KyouSaya won the pairing wars long ago. The overwhelming majority of fics, doujins, and art are MadoHomu and KyouSaya. If you want that, you're spoiled for choice. Compared to fandoms like Harry Potter, where shippers of the canon pairing are a distinct minority, I'd say the PMMM fandom doesn't need any fixing to make sure people know who the top dogs are. You're like a gay man screaming "GAY PRIDE! I'M OUT AND I'M PROUD!" in the streets of San Francisco.

And to close my argument: First, you also have a Tumblr. You use it to anonymously harass others, because you know that, given the choice, no sane person would listen to you. Second, I think it's hilarious that you brought up a link to that poor bastard's profile. Not only because it's not me (what, you think I'm the only one unoriginal enough to have "acefighter159" as my username? It's "cool word and some numbers;" that's about as pleb as it gets), but because it implies that you, for whom the mods on /u/ have a ban-on-sight directive, could ever rally people to raid someone. Third...

http://i.imgur.com/Q272hh8.png

Bingo!

Base +6, Centifolia +10, simplesimon32 +25, Ashvinoth +6, @43883 +35, poldek123 +5, Mantama +9

If something doesn't fit your personal ship, please ignore it and move on. Let plebeians enjoy their garbage in peace.

This section is for reviews, not arguments.

Base +9, simplesimon32 +25, @43883 +35, Mantama +9

GOD fucking dammit; not this shit again...
I'm going back to having fun imagining any possible yuri situation in PMMM.

........................
...On that note, I don't have a damn clue about the plot happenings of this doujin...

Base +5, Centifolia +10, @43883 +35, Mantama +9

Well, only if I understood of the situation enough to generate the empathy needed.
Someday, I will learn enough Japanese to properly read this doujin. Today will not be that day.

And even if I gained enough insight (plus the unsanctioned angst) for this fanwork to offend me, I'd still know when to SHUT THE FUCK UP.

Last edited on 16 January 2015, 23:13.

Base +5, Centifolia +10, @43883 +35, Mantama +9

ROFLOL!!! You're funny, man! You suggested I read a 5000+ word manifesto you posted on a comment thread! Good one!!

-
Well, so that I don't invalidate my entire rationale, I need to stop adding comments to this page, NOW.
I genuinely hope you enjoy wearing out your keyboard waiting for a response.

Sincerely,
Me

Base +5, Centifolia +10, simplesimon32 +25, @43883 +35, Mantama +9

TL: https://pastebin.com/7BAmi4TJ

Base +6