https://book.dmm.co.jp/product/4275226/k568agotp01948

紧急射爆事件发生！

Base +4, david31476 -6, p2019 +6, kkyykk1992 +6, zngfukl +6, 血滴丹田 +6, i can fang +4, lsp520 +6, Double_Pillars +6, chenzhenb +2, AMBER BLAKE +6, Coledas Ukgent +14

米拉小姐，嘶哈嘶哈

Base +6, 血滴丹田 +6, Coledas Ukgent +14

Based Nanao, a decade long serie I think ? So good.

Base +6, yupokamusi -8, Coledas Ukgent +14

thank you for the sharing

Base +6, yupokamusi -8, Coledas Ukgent +14

冲冲冲！手冲战士在行动！！

Base +6, taohei +4, lsp520 +6, sehy7 +5, Coledas Ukgent +14

还是看漫画有感觉 动画都是一坨答辩

Base +4, gjh373033667 +6, Huhiuman +2, 千羽幻风 -6, ws91yxs +4, sumlll +6, diablo1100 +5, Double_Pillars +6, a2411657206 +6, .nmsl +1, smashingYO +13, hentaibignicer +6, 777zero +2, and 2 more...

我今天就是要用米拉小姐冲死在这里

Base +3, 血滴丹田 +6, Coledas Ukgent +14

Yeah, this is, in fact, a master work.

Base +6, riwamixer99 +13, Coledas Ukgent +14

bruuuuhhh! this is top calibre! thx for sharing!! now time to put this on the harddrive!

Base +6, riwamixer99 +13, Coledas Ukgent +14

感觉画的没之前好用了...现在的锥子脸+健美身材很难冲的动

Base +2, a767187219 +6, sunfanchao +6, scf123 +23, 仓央嘉措、 +6, wjh43 +6, KINGggggoooo +5, david31476 +6, 哥书包有砖头 +6, diablo1100 +5, Double_Pillars +6, kevinfllay +6, salatuojia +6, and 6 more...

Nanao！永远的神！这个系列太无敌了！

Base +6, 血滴丹田 +6, chenzhenb +2, Coledas Ukgent +14

They're masterworks all, you can't go wrong.

Base +16, shockroach +6, riwamixer99 +13, dgssss +6, Sirpunishment +6, Hazuki_300 +5, xieghart +6, Coledas Ukgent +14

The new drawings are not made by master nanao, the style is completely different. 4 years ago I was able to contact the teacher, this year I tried again but he no longer responds. I think they took his work from the master and that is why the story and the drawings are completely different from what the master originally planned. You just have to see page 79, it's an unpleasant face that more seems to be made by butcha u.
The master's drawings are refined and delicate. You can see all his previous works and you will not find those grotesque faces which abound in the new works.

Base +6, Gentleking +6, maniakiss -7, johnschiffer -6, lolz12344 +6, smashingYO +13, Alcrian -6, Fcrosser -6, QCopter +6, rogue_gamecube -7, kafi +8, Coledas Ukgent +14, korthin -7

@Ieracles "My source is that I made it the fuck up"?

Base +6, Alcrian +6, Fcrosser +6, Coledas Ukgent +14, korthin +7

@aby2sal
No, it only compares the old draws with the new ones.
I don't mean it badly, but they need to train their eyes. Find artist friends and show them drawings of master piece and then show them drawings of 3 piece nursing or gold. They will tell you the same as me: They are not the same artist.
I'm not looking for them to hate. I'm also a fan of master nanao's work. I'm just saying and this is my hypothesis that nanao and comic exe disagreed and comic exe stayed with 3 piece and that's why they continue it with another artist and nanao says that they are his updates to avoid getting into more problems. I repeat it is my hypothesis.
As evidence:
If you compare the drawings, the most obvious is the hair, the hair that Nanao draws is like a lot of pretty wavy ribbons that get tangled up with each other, the new hair is rough, just straight lines.
The faces, before they were all different and well distinguishable, the new faces are all the same face with different hair.And so there are many details in the nipples, the way the mouth is drawn, the head shapes, the breast sizes, the anatomy, etc. I know this because I studied the master's drawing when I was making a masterpiece doujin, but unfortunately my hard drive burned and everything was lost.

Also remember that a new heroine was going to enter the story /s/a0e5d2a0c4/2127234-83
2 piece also not continuous.
Whether Mira San was a widow or her husband was away was also not clarified.
In the anime, it is said that she is a widow. In the original work, it was not clarified.

4 years ago I wrote to the teacher to ask his permission to make a master piece doujin. First I congratulated him for his work, thinking that he would never answer me, but he did answer me, I wrote him a second time asking for his permission to make a doujin and he told me that he would see it, but never i finished it. A few months ago I wrote to him again to ask if he was okay and he never responded. It seems incredible, I thought it impossible myself, but famous artists do respond to messages, I also received responses from Kakage and Jim Lee and other comic and manga artists, I ask them for advice and 90% do respond. If you don't believe me try it.

I see that my comment has received a lot of hate, but I don't do it meanly, I wish them the best, if we are here it is because we share a taste for Nanao's work and for Tsubakihara Mira San.

Base +6, gashberu +6, johnschiffer -6, Alcrian -6, Fcrosser -6, QCopter +6, rogue_gamecube -7, maniakiss +7, Coledas Ukgent +14, korthin -7

@ Ieracles Okay, I'm taking your words seriously.
I somewhat have to agree with you on the hair, they do look different. Regarding the faces, nipples, mouth, etc, I have to admit that I don't know. I can't look at "Master Piece" that long, the saturation of that work (or at least the version I downloaded) had too high saturation which made it quite painful for the eyes. I would appreciate it if you could provide some samples.

I find it confusing how you're using the words Teacher or Master when you mention Nanao. I assume you want to show respect to the artist, but it's hard to keep up.

I would like to talk more about this and some other things, so I sent you a message on the forums. Hope you got the time.

Base +6, Coledas Ukgent +14

here is the ultimate proof.
Compare: The original drawings are three-dimensional, they are of better quality, made by a professional hand, and the changes, instead of improving the quality, are much worse.

Nanao
/s/2f32cc5fa5/2398427-8
/s/d770c83515/1310513-3
/s/141d671d33/1310513-5
/s/26fb8c5bdd/2398427-1
fake artist
/s/24a4fc7981/2452060-46
/s/79a873082b/2452060-21
/s/06d36a31f9/2452060-23
/s/aa95b2d2ff/2452060-36

Why do the changes look worse? Artists get better over time. They don't get worse.

Base +6, gashberu +6, diablo1100 +5, johnschiffer -6, lolz12344 +6, PPlebeian +7, seeker555 +13, Coledas Ukgent +14, korthin -7

更多的米拉小姐！

Base +6, Coledas Ukgent +14

Yes, I can see your point now. That's painful to think about. I also apologize for being rude earlier and thank you for bringing this up. Do you know where I can follow the original artist?

Last edited on 01 February 2023, 04:34.

Base +6, Coledas Ukgent +14

我超，合订本

Base +4, Coledas Ukgent +14

@aby2sal
I understand you. Before I learned to draw, I also saw all the intermediate level drawings as unbelievable and I couldn't differentiate them from a professional drawing, I couldn't find the mistakes, for me they were the same. Now my eyes are trained and I can easily see mistakes, that's why details that are subtle for normal people are very obvious for an artist.

Nanao stopped updating her networks a long time ago, she even deleted some. You can have a look at them here:
https://twitter.com/mahayang0128
http://mahayoung.blog106.fc2.com/

Base +6, gashberu +6, diablo1100 +5, johnschiffer -6, Fcrosser -6, Coledas Ukgent +14

@leracles
Yeah, the whole thing where there's a fake artist drawing the newer doujins is kind of complete bullshit. First off, if Comic Exe replaced Nanao at some point, then the changes would not be reflected in Nanao's other works outside of Comic ExE. His Fate fanart for instance looks closer to his newer Comic ExE works. And that stuff is fairly recent as well. Also, yes, some artists do degrade with time. You can look at a hundreds of manga and light novels who's art gradually declines with time. Look at an artist like Ponkan8 who's art you can see gradually decline over the course of the Oregairu novels, with the final novels art looking nothing like the art of the first few. My guess is that Nanao's art style just changed to help produce stuff faster, and meet deadlines rather than being replaced. This stuff happens all the time in the industry. It's just plain the most likely scenario than the theory that the artist was replaced because the new art is different and he won't answer your emails.

Base +6, wjh43 +6, memnarch +11, baha815 +11, momoyo +13, Alcrian +6, aided +29, Fcrosser +6, rogue_gamecube +7, Masuu +6, sohaiz +6, Coledas Ukgent +14, Teh_Red_Guy +12

@pik3rob I can understand that logic, but is there actually a need to downgrade your work just so that it matches with the new style?

Base +6, Coledas Ukgent +14

@leracles

我更倾向你的观点，因为2018年他画了个尼托克里斯后说了这么一句：前回のニトさんから試験的にクリスタオンリーで描いてたのですが、思ってたより使い易かったのと変なブラシいっぱいあって触ってて楽しい。https://twitter.com/mahayang0128/status/1043834542665084928
在那一段时间，也正好是他画风变化的时期。当然要阴谋论的话，NANAO这个笔名背后的画家换了也是可能的（笑

当年MATER PIECE那么大的宣传力度，最后它在虎之穴上R18漫画全年销量统计却只是全年26名。说实话也挺让人惋惜的，我以为就算没有前五，也能进前十吧。没想到二十名开外了。
个人瞎猜是当时对比其他漫画定价太高的原因导致的。
不过现在的画风感觉真不如以前用心了，呜呜。

Base +6, Coledas Ukgent +14, diablo1100 +6

@aby2sal
Consistency mostly. For instance, the example I used of Ponkan8 remade the first Oregairu cover for their art book.

Base +6, Coledas Ukgent +14

@pik3rob
As I said it is my hypothesis.
Artists vary their styles, but carry vices, maintain certain particularities that make them recognizable. Jim Lee, Eichiro Oda, David Finch, Alvien Lee, etc. You can see his best and worst drawings but there is something that creeps and stays that is present in that badly done and ugly drawing and it is also in that well done drawing and allows you to recognize the artist who did it.
Nanao maintains that in her first drawings when she didn't know how to draw /s/04235b1e34/593174-2 and in her best drawings when she already had a consolidated style. But suddenly you switch to a whole new style without dragging anything from your old style? Not even to say that it is due to time, because even in quick sketches those particularities are maintained.

In short, if my opinion is bullshit to you, I accept that. But the evidence is there, and if it weren't so obvious, we wouldn't be having this discussion.

Finally Nanao had a fetish that he himself confessed, a part of the anatomy that he enjoyed drawing that in the new installments also disappeared.

@akahara1999

I read it, if I'm not mistaken then I draw 3 piece autumn saying that I had found a faster way to draw and that's why this is the one with the least quality compared to the others in the master piece collection, but all the elements that do Nanao are still there. I believe that if it were about saving time, the new jobs would be of 3piece autumn quality.

我读了它，如果我没记错的话，我画了 3piece autumn 说我找到了一种更快的绘画方法，这就是为什么这是与杰作系列中的其他作品相比质量最低的原因，但所有元素那做 nanao 还在那里。我相信，如果是为了节省时间，新的工作将是 3piece 秋季质量。

Last edited on 01 February 2023, 08:33.

Base +6, diablo1100 +5, johnschiffer -6, Fcrosser -6, rogue_gamecube -7, Masuu -6, sohaiz -6, QCopter +6, seeker555 +13, Coledas Ukgent +14, korthin -7

I can also see the change however I still think its within nanao's style and its closer to her light novel art style. And if we need to bring in conspiracy theory about artist being replace can we also take a look at Niro lol?

Base +9, Coledas Ukgent +14

米拉小姐真是完美的女人！

Base +6, Coledas Ukgent +14

这本没订成实体本，遗憾了

Base +6, Coledas Ukgent +14

80页开始的Gold之前出过么，好像没看过

Base +6, Coledas Ukgent +14

闭着眼睛五颗星

Base +4, Coledas Ukgent +14

锥子脸健美身材在他画lovelive本的时候就是这样啊，这才是原本的画风，可以说是不忘初心了

Base +8, yyiii +22, NIGAIA +5, Actros0 +6, Coledas Ukgent +14

Or perhaps the magazine version had received inputs from the magazine publisher, those cannot extend to the tankoubon copyright agreement?

Base +6, Coledas Ukgent +14

点赞！！！

Base +4, Coledas Ukgent +14

这作者肯定读书时候老跑女生游泳社团，以前还没看出来现在健美身材有点冲不太动

Base +7, Coledas Ukgent +14

和服那篇是重画版，和杂志连载的不一样了，喜欢哪个见仁见智了

Base +6, Coledas Ukgent +14

中
[ななお] 3Piece ～Swimsuit～ (コミック エグゼ 12) [中国翻訳] [DL版]
/g/1233362/e5c1031c7b/
[ななお] 3Piece ～YUKATA～ (コミック エグゼ 15) [中国翻訳] [DL版]
/g/1310513/65fd7ea433/
[ななお] 3Piece～Valentine～ (コミック エグゼ 17) [中国翻訳] [DL版]
/g/1368729/a4e77e805e/
[ななお] 3Piece ~Maid Clothes~ (コミック エグゼ 23) [中国翻訳] [DL版]
/g/1585485/bf8220b6ed/
[ななお] 3Piece～Diet～ (コミック エグゼ 31) [中国翻訳] [DL版]
/g/1954462/c3fdfc295f/
[ななお] 3Piece～Nursing～ (コミック エグゼ 37) [中国翻訳] [DL版]
/g/2280377/c8e87a24fc/

插圖
コミック エグゼ 39 [DL版]
/s/a3d7e8ac58/2355897-4
/s/8793fbdc53/2355897-5

單行本
[ななお] Master_ Piece
/g/1204515/82701d931d/

Base +7, 冷之兔 +6, yzy276 +6, negifish +12, 45687533 +7, Coledas Ukgent +14, 陈胜胜 +6

有没有汉化组啊

Base +4, plongling +6, 斯特朗炮 +2, 9XX6X +6, Coledas Ukgent +14

还以为是全新内容呢，结果是整合啊

Base +1, Coledas Ukgent +14

看来米拉系列这次多了个gold篇
期待翻译

Last edited on 24 March 2023, 05:48.

Base +6, Coledas Ukgent +14

和服篇哪里重画了？对比看了没什么大致区别啊？

Base +2, Coledas Ukgent +14

这作者怎么出产量这么低啊，后续几乎没有本子了，最新一集里番质量也低，日本涩情行业越来越烂了，都是被谁养起来又是被谁把风气带坏的，干脆不要搞色情了

Base +6, Hoshikawayozora -4, Coledas Ukgent +14

相比之下，动画就是依托答辩！

Base +6, Coledas Ukgent +14

一個連色情都不能打對字的地方說日本越來越爛 搞笑了吧

Base +6, 混沌膜导师 -6, freedom lu -6, NFKK -6, Hoshikawayozora +4, Coledas Ukgent +14, ConnorM -6, therethere +13, xianshiyonghuming -6

等我死了我也要把这些打印出来贴在我的棺材里

Base +6, Coledas Ukgent +14, excre +7

You can't tell me that

/s/2bdd6c395a/2452060-27

looks worse than

/s/1040ea0f19/1308656-9

A lot of the changes are so minute it's hard to notice and then some are radically different. I honestly think the changes are just to have more of a consistent style for a tank.

Base +7, Coledas Ukgent +14

lol wtf are these schizo ramblings

"nanao-sama won't answer my emails, they must be retired!"

bucko you're a creep, that's why nanao stopped responding

Base +6